_green.jpg)
Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Accepting Orders
Delivery fee -
Min. order - $0.00
Free delivery above
Pickup
Delivery
Dine-In
Pickup time: Up to 300 minutes
Pickup Address: Fishers, IN 46038
Kay's Cupcakes
Kay's Sweet Tooth offers some of the most amazing cupcakes you'll ever taste. Please see different sections listed with multiple options available to meet you needs.
Gourmet Cupcakes
These unique cupcakes come with a special topping made from scratch. These Cupcakes can NOT be decorated. Each dozen are priced with the flavor. If you would like a variety option, please choose that in this section.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Kay's Classic
These cupcakes consist of a classic cupcake flavor of either vanilla, chocolate, yellow, or strawberry. Topped with a vanilla or chocolate buttercream icing. These cupcakes can not be decorated. You can choose up to two flavors per dozen.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Decorated Cupcake
Our decorated cupcakes come by the dozen. Choose from any flavor cupcake topped with a vanilla butter cream icing to match what ever theme or color scheme of your choice.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Kay's Touch
These cupcake options are decorated with your color of choice. They will also come with a special occasion tag of your choice (Happy Birthday, Happy Mothers/Fathers Day, Baby Shower, etc). Details to be added at checkout. HAVE TO BE ORDERED 3 WEEKS IN ADVANCE TO ALLOW FOR CUSTOM TAGS TO BE MADE.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Cookies
A variety of cookie flavors that are uniquely put together.
*PLEASE ALLOW 2-3 DAYS FOR ORDER PROCESSING*
Cookies
A variety of cookies with amazing flavor! Any cookie order can come half and half, up to 2 flavors per dozen. Please specify at checkout.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Grazed by Kay's
The makings of creative flavorful charcuterie items and so many more. The Art of Gathering.
There will be a quantity minimum when ordering, please see details of each item.
The Art of Gathering
The art of gathering. This section is designated to all things charcuterie and assorted boards.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Kay's Cake
13 inch 2 layer letter or number cake. Vanilla butter cream and custom tags of your choice. Has to be ordered at least 3 weeks in advance.
Letter & Number cakes
13 inch letter or number cake. Vanilla butter cream icing with custom cake toppers to match your theme of choice. Order has to be placed at least 3 weeks before event.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
1/4 quarter Sheet Cake
One flavor of cake with your choice of icing flavors. Happy Birthday tags included. Options for custom tag.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Heart Cake
2 layered cake of your choice. Each cake comes with a happy birthday tag (custom tags can be added). Cakes with custom tags have to be ordered at least 2 weeks in advance.
This section is next available for ordering on September 20th at 9:00AM.
Ready to order?